the green why
← home
20th century

The ideas of the 19th century kill people in the 20th

What happened — and why
The First and Second World Wars
Seventeen million dead in the First. Seventy million in the Second. The Holocaust. Hiroshima.
The philosophical cause
Camus — Nietzsche to Hitler (through distortion). Marx to Lenin to Stalin. Hegel to nationalism to ethnic states. The ideas of the 19th century taken literally.
Camus: the absurd is the only honest position. Berdyaev: the Russian catastrophe as a spiritual diagnosis. Heidegger himself supported Nazism — and kept silent.
The Gulag (1918–1956)
The system of Soviet camps. By various estimates, between 1.5 and 1.8 million died directly in the camps, and millions more through related repressions.
The philosophical cause
Berdyaev — Marx: class enemies objectively obstruct progress. Lenin: therefore they must be destroyed. Stalin: carried out consistently.
Berdyaev had foreseen this as early as 1918 in "The Philosophy of Inequality," for which he was expelled from Russia on the "Philosophers' Ship."
Thinkers and figures of the century
Russian version
🇬🇧EN